Pipe Tobacco Reviews

Small Batch Cigar

We use a unique method of rating pipe tobacco based on the quality of experience observed during multiple phases of the smoke, with a maximum perfect score of 10.0  Each category is weighted to a specific ratio depending on how drastically it affects the experience.

PIPE TOBACCO RATING SYSTEM

Craft & Aesthetic …….. 0.50
Tin Aroma …….. 0.50
Lighting Process …….. 0.50
Smoking Experience …….. 8.00
Personal Enjoyment …….. 0.50

  • ALL
  • Ashton
  • Astley's
  • C&D
  • Captain Black
  • Dan Tobacco
  • Erik Stokkebye
  • GLP
  • Lane Limited
  • MacBaren
  • McClelland
  • Peter Stokkebye
  • Peterson
  • Pipe Tobacco Reviews
  • Planta
  • Rattray's
  • Samuel Gawith
  • Scanavian Tobacco Group
  • Standard Tobacco Group
  • Sutliff
  • Watch City Cigar
  • Wessex

Pipe Tobacco Review: Boswell Pipes Railroad Station

Wessex Red Virginia Flake

Pipe Tobacco Review: GL Pease Barbary Coast

Pipe Tobacco Review: Rattray’s Black Mallory

Pipe Tobacco Review: McClelland Beacon

Sutliff English: Majestic English and Count Pulaski

Wessex Brown Virginia Flake

C&D Burley Sleepers: Pegasus and Habana Daydream

Solani Virginia Flake 633

Cobblestone Outdoors Hiking

Boswell Aromatics: Berry Cobbler, Raspberry Cream, and Dan’s Blend

Samuel Gawith Best Brown Flake

Pipe Tobacco Review: Sutliff J4

Watch City Cigar Simply Orange

Cornell and Diehl’s Innismouth

Sutliff Cringle Flake 2021

Daughter’s and Ryan Two Timer

Astley’s No. 44 Dark Virginia Flake

Pipe Tobacco Review: Ashton’s Artisan’s Blend

Pipe Tobacco Review: MacBaren HH Old Dark Fired

Boswell’s Northwood

Pipe Tobacco Review: Erik Stokkebye 4th Generation Evening Flake is Great “Factory Fresh”

Samuel Gawith Skiff Mixture

Pipe Tobacco Review: Wessex Brigade Original Scores High for Malty, Salty Sweetness

Pipe Tobacco Review: C&D Engine #99 Could Be the Best Smoky Bulk Blend Ever

Pipe Tobacco Review: Five Brothers Is a Terrific Smoke With a Deep History

These Bulk Pipe Tobaccos Are Great for Aging in the Cellar

Peter Stokkebye PS 41 Cube Cut

Pipe Tobacco Review: Sutliff Cringle Flake 2019 Has Great Flavor But Doesn’t Stay Lit

Pipe Tobacco Review: ‘Corn Cob Pipe and a Button Nose’ Has Terrific Packaging But Awful Flavor

Pipe Tobacco Review: Lane HGL Is an Aromatic Blend With a Small Sweet Spot

Pipe Tobacco Review: McClelland Frog Morton Is a Rich, Flavorful Smoke

Everything You Need to Know to About Smoking Pipe Tobacco

Pipe Tobacco Review: Wessex Gold Slice