Cigar Reviews

We use a unique method of rating cigars based on the quality of experience observed during multiple phases of the smoke, with a maximum perfect score of 10.0  Each category is weighted to a specific ratio depending on how drastically it affects the experience.


Craft & Aesthetic …….. 0.80
Pre-light Characteristics …….. 0.50
Lighting Process …….. 0.50
Smoking Experience …….. 6.90
Personal Enjoyment …….. 0.50

  • ALL
  • Black Label Trading Co.
  • Black Works Studio
  • Byron
  • Caldwell
  • CAO
  • Casdagli Cigars
  • Cigar Federation
  • Crowned Heads
  • Dapper Cigar Co
  • Davidoff
  • Drew Estate
  • Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust
  • Epic
  • Ezra Zion
  • Fable
  • Foundation
  • Isabela
  • L'Atelier
  • Matt Booth
  • Micallef Cigars
  • Room101
  • Stolen Throne

Dapper El Borracho

Davidoff Millennium Blend Lonsdale (2007)

Davidoff Millennium Blend Toro

Davidoff Yamasa Robusto

Drew Estate Pappy Van Winkle Robusto

Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Muestra de Saka Nacatamale

Ezra Zion (Pre)Eminence

Ezra Zion All My Exes Lancero

Ezra Zion Bee’s Knees

Ezra Zion Blessed Leaf Doxology

Ezra Zion Brass Knuckles

Ezra Zion Burnt Ends

Ezra Zion Chocolate Porter

Ezra Zion Fried Chicken Xtra Crispy

Ezra Zion Green Army Men

Ezra Zion Honor Series: Ronald Reagan 40th

Ezra Zion Live Free or Die

Ezra Zion Naughty Bits

Ezra Zion Punkin’ Pie

Ezra Zion The Raven

Fable Fourth Prime

Foundation El Gueguense

Isabela Time-Traveler 2019 Limited Edition

L’Atelier Cote d’Or 2017 L.E.

Stolen Throne Crook of the Crown