Cigar Reviews

We use a unique method of rating cigars based on the quality of experience observed during multiple phases of the smoke, with a maximum perfect score of 10.0  Each category is weighted to a specific ratio depending on how drastically it affects the experience.

CIGAR REVIEWS & RATING SYSTEM

Craft & Aesthetic …….. 0.80
Pre-light Characteristics …….. 0.50
Lighting Process …….. 0.50
Smoking Experience …….. 7.70
Personal Enjoyment …….. 0.50

  • ALL
  • Aging Room
  • Black Label Trading Co.
  • Black Works Studio
  • Byron
  • Caldwell
  • CAO
  • Casdagli Cigars
  • Cigar Federation
  • Crowned Heads
  • Dapper Cigar Co
  • Davidoff
  • Drew Estate
  • Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust
  • Epic
  • Ezra Zion
  • Fable
  • Foundation
  • Isabela
  • L'Atelier
  • Matt Booth
  • Micallef Cigars
  • My Father Cigars S.A.
  • Padron
  • Room101
  • Stolen Throne

Cigar Review: Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Espressivo Is Definitely Not Its Award-Winning Sibling

Cigar Review: The Promising My Father Fonseca Cosacos Is a Disappointment