Cigar Reviews

Small Batch Cigar

We use a unique method of rating cigars based on the quality of experience observed during multiple phases of the smoke, with a maximum perfect score of 10.0  Each category is weighted to a specific ratio depending on how drastically it affects the experience.

CIGAR REVIEWS & RATING SYSTEM

Craft & Aesthetic …….. 0.80
Pre-light Characteristics …….. 0.50
Lighting Process …….. 0.50
Smoking Experience …….. 7.70
Personal Enjoyment …….. 0.50

  • ALL
  • ADVentura Cigars
  • Aganorsa Leaf
  • Aging Room
  • AJ Fernandez Cigars
  • Alec & Bradley
  • All Saints Cigars
  • Altadis
  • Arnold André
  • Arturo Fuente
  • AVO
  • Bella Dama Cigars
  • Black Label Trading Co.
  • Black Works Studio
  • Blackbird Cigar Co.
  • Blanco Cigars
  • Byron
  • Caldwell
  • CAO
  • Casa 1910
  • Casdagli Cigars
  • Cavalier Genève
  • Chogüí Cigars
  • Cigar Clowns
  • Cigar Federation
  • Crowned Heads
  • Dapper Cigar Co.
  • Davidoff
  • Deep South Cigars
  • Dissident
  • Drew Estate
  • DROP
  • Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust
  • E.P. Carrillo
  • Epic
  • Espinosa
  • Ezra Zion
  • Fable
  • Ferio Tego
  • Foundation
  • H. Upmann
  • HVC Cigars
  • Isabela
  • J London
  • Jake Wyatt Cigars
  • Joya de Nicaragua
  • L'Atelier
  • La Aroma de Cuba
  • Lampert Cigars
  • LH Premium Cigars
  • Lost & Found
  • Luciano Cigars
  • Lure Cigars
  • Macanudo
  • Micallef Cigars
  • My Father Cigars S.A.
  • OneOff
  • Oxford Cigar Company
  • Ozgener Family Cigars
  • Padron
  • Partagas
  • Patina
  • Perdomo
  • Peter James
  • Plasencia
  • Powstanie Cigars
  • Punch
  • Reinado Cigars
  • Rojas Cigars
  • RoMa Craft
  • Room101
  • Smoking Jacket
  • Somm Cigars
  • Southern Draw
  • Stolen Throne
  • Tatuaje
  • Warped
  • West Tampa Tobacco Co.

Cigar Review: Cavalier LE 2024

Cigar Review: The Evening Primrose from Southern Draw

Cigar Review: Catastrophic Failure from Powstanie

Cigar Review: E.P. Carrillo Honduras Toro

Cigar Review: Las Calaveras Décimo Aniversario by Crowned Heads

Cigar Review: Maestranza Valencia by RoMa Craft

Cigar Review: My Father Le Bijou 1922 100 Años Corona Extra (2024)

Cigar Review: OneOff Black

Cigar Review: Coffin Nails by Black Label Trading Co.

Cigar Review: Tempura White Series by Cavalier Genève

Cigar Review: Dragon Fire by Punch

Cigar Review: Fiat Lux Tenebrus Limited Edition from Luciano Cigars

Cigar Review: AGANORSA Leaf Arsenio Toro

Cigar Review: Daughters of the Wind Robusto (Pony) from Casdagli Cigars

Cigar Review: La Bomba 601 Warhead X

Cigar Review: Blue Eyed Jack’s Revenge by Adventura

Cigar Review: Mi Querida by Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust

Cigar Review: Sobremesa Brûlée Wagashi from Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust

Cigar Review: S84 Shade to Black Corona Doble by Drew Estate

Cigar Review: Smoking Jacket’s Mini Henkie

Cigar Review: Cosecha 151 Robusto by Plasencia

Cigar Review: Patina Cigars’ Oro de Nicaragua Toro Extra

Cigar Review: Micallef Blue

Cigar Review: The Conqueror by ADVentura Cigars

Cigar Review: La Vereda by Crowned Heads

Cigar Review: Cinco De Cinco by Joya De Nicaragua

Cigar Review: Prince Hall Square by Blanco Cigars

Cigar Review: Casdagli “Brothers of the Sabre” Forrader

Cigar Review: All Saints Cigar Solamente (2023)

Cigar Review: Las Calaveras Edicion Limatada 2023 LC54 from Crowned Heads

Cigar Review: Lomo de Cerdo from Tatuaje

Cigar Review: Four Kicks Mule Kick 2023 by Crowned Heads

Cigar Review: New World Dorado Toro by AJ Fernandez Cigars

Cigar Review: Y Panda Toro by Luciano Cigars

Cigar Review: El Gueguense Macho Raton by Foundation Cigars

Cigar Review: Club Mareva Jure from Casdagli Cigars

Cigar Review: The Somm BDX Gordo

Cigar Review: Highclere Castle Petite Corona by Foundation Cigars

Cigar Review: West Tampa Tobacco Co. Red Toro

Cigar Review: Lampert Cigars Ocean Breeze

Cigar Review: Patina Sumatra Rustic

Cigar Review: H. Upmann Nicaragua AJ Fernandez Heritage

Cigar Review: The Attic from West Tampa Tobacco Co.

Cigar Review: Louis the Last from Caldwell Cigars

Cigar Review: Luciano “The Dreamer” Hermoso No. 4

Cigar Review: Rojas Street Taco Toro

Cigar Review: Cosecha 149 by Plasencia

Cigar Review: Cultura by Warped

Cigar Review: Cavalry Edition As de Oro by Casa 1910

Cigar Review: Molotov by Dissident Cigars

Cigar Review: Las Calaveras Edición Limitada 2022 by Crowned Heads

Cigar Review: Highclere Castle Senetjer by Foundation Cigars

Drew Estate Liga Privada No. 9 Cigar Review

Cigar Review: Red Meat Lovers 2022 Beef Stick by Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust

Cigar Review: Tatuaje 7th Tuxtla

Cigar Review: Drew Estate Undercrown Sun Grown Dogma

Cigar Review Rethink: Micallef A

Cigar Review: West Tampa Tobacco Co. Black Toro

Cigar Review: West Tampa Tobacco Co. White Toro

Cigar Review: Los Estoico 54 Maduro from Peter James

Cigar Review: J London Gold Series Toro

Cigar Review: Warped Cigars’ Nicotina

Cigar Review: Micallef Cigars Reata Corona Extra

Cigar Review: 15 Minutes of Fame from Lost & Found

Cigar Review: Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Sobremesa Brûlée Toro

Cigar Review: Companion from Warped Cigars

Cigar Review: Four Kicks Mule Kick Limited Edition 2022

Cigar Review: Tatuaje Cohetes Capa Especial (2022)

Cigar Review: Arturo Fuente Anejo Shark No. 77

Cigar Review: Chogüí Dos77 Rogusto Extra (2022)

Cigar Review: Jake Wyatt’s Lithium Lancero

Cigar Review: La Historia Regalias d’Celia (Belicoso) from E.P. Carrillo

Cigar Review: El Oso Mama (2022) from Warped

Cigar Review: Guardian of the Farm Cerberus Toro from Aganorsa Leaf

Cigar Review: Punch Fu Manchu

Plasencia Alma Fuerte Generacion V Salomon

Cigar Review: El Oso Blanco from Warped Cigars

Cigar Review: The Macaw from Blackbird Cigar Co.

Cigar Review: Muestra de Saka – Unstolen Valor

Cigar Review: La Aroma de Cuba Pasión Marveloso

Cigar Review: Cigar Clowns Festivus

Cigar Review: Lampert Cigars’ 1675 Edición AZUL Robusto

Cigar Review: Tatuaje Cohetes Broadleaf (2022)

Cigar Review: 20 Acre Farm from Drew Estate is a Solid Release with Burn Issues

Cigar Review: Fiat Lux Insight by ACE Prime

Cigar Review: Warped’s La Hacienda First Growth

Cigar Review: The Elegancia Proclaims Ferio Tego’s Arrival

Cigar Review: The Jornal from Oxford Cigar Company is an Exceptional House Blend

Cigar Review: The Partagas Cortado is a Different Kind of Connecticut

Cigar Review: Stolen Throne’s War Council

Cigar Review: Cigar Culture’s Hawk by Blackbird Cigar Co. Crash Lands

Cigar Review: Sweep the Leg from Nomad by Ezra Zion is a Solid Hit

Cigar Review: The Absurd from DROP Rings in the Holidays

Cigar Review: AVO Syncro Caribe Toro Delivers a Taste of the Caribbean

Cigar Review: The Bella Doma Ace Makes for a Perfect Hand

Cigar Review: HVC 10th Anniversary

Cigar Review: Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniversary Champagne is a Mixed Bag

Cigar Review: Reinado Cigars Returns with the Grand Apex

Cigar Review: Lithium from Jake Wyatt Cigar Co. Will Take You on a Journey

Cigar Review: RoMa Craft Neanderthal and the Evolution of Pepper

Cigar Review: LH Cigars Colorado Toro

Cigar Review: The CHC Serie E 5150 from Crowned Heads Really Got Me

Cigar Review: Villa Casdagli Toro Lives Up to its Namesake

Cigar Review: My Father Flor de las Antillas is a Great Introductory Smoke

Cigar Review: The Alec & Bradley Kintsugi Robusto is a Work of Art

Cigar Review: Deep South Cigars 770 BBC is More than Pun

Cigar Review: Casdagli’s Enigma Solves the Mystery of a Truly Special Experience

Cigar Review: Casdagli Cigars Mareva Spalato No. 2 Is Worth the Price of Admission

Cigar Review: Ninjaragua from Joya de Nicaragua and Cigar Dojo Is All Gimmick

Cigar Review: Liga Privada H99 Is a Must-Try Stick From Drew Estate’s Prestigious Line

Cigar Review: Padrón Damaso No. 15 ain’t Your Daddy’s Connecticut

Cigar Review: The FREAKSHOW From Nomad by Ezra Zion Is No Laughing Matter

Cigar Review: Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Espressivo Is Definitely Not Its Award-Winning Sibling

Cigar Review: The Promising My Father Fonseca Cosacos Is a Disappointment

Cigar Review: Stolen Throne Oath Taker Tastes Beautiful But Is Tainted by Burn Issues

Cigar Review: AJ Fernandez Enclave Salomon Looks Great But Fails on Flavor

Cigar Review: Epic Maduro Robusto Is a Full-Bodied, But Nuanced Smoke

Room101 Doomsayer “Passive” Habano Review

Epic Cigars Project E San Andres Gran Ola

Casdagli Daughters of the Wind Cremello

Micallef Cigars “To Be Named” Maduro

Stolen Throne Crook of the Crown

L’Atelier Cote d’Or 2017 L.E.

Foundation El Gueguense

Isabela Time-Traveler 2019 Limited Edition

Fable Fourth Prime

Ezra Zion (Pre)Eminence

Ezra Zion Live Free or Die

Ezra Zion Chocolate Porter

Ezra Zion Honor Series: Ronald Reagan 40th

Ezra Zion Burnt Ends

Dapper El Borracho

Ezra Zion Blessed Leaf Doxology

Ezra Zion Bee’s Knees

Drew Estate Pappy Van Winkle Robusto

Davidoff Yamasa Robusto

Davidoff Millennium Blend Toro

Davidoff Millennium Blend Lonsdale (2007)

Dapper La Madrina

Dapper Cubo Maduro

Crowned Heads Angel’s Anvil 2016 LE

Cigar Federation Honey Badger DGAF

Cigar Federation 729 Calloway Lane

CAO Amazon Basin (Original Release)

Caldwell Eastern Standard Midnight Express

Byron Londinenses Reserva 5 Anos

Black Works Studio Green Hornet Kato

Foundation Tabernacle Havana Seed CT #142

Davidoff Seleccion 702 LE (2018 Release)

Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Muestra de Saka Nacatamale

Ezra Zion The Raven

Ezra Zion Fried Chicken Xtra Crispy

Ezra Zion All My Exes Lancero

Ezra Zion Naughty Bits

Ezra Zion Brass Knuckles

Ezra Zion Punkin’ Pie

Ezra Zion Green Army Men